Revisiting Moscow-Petushki: Russophobic?

I received an interesting message from Yuri Gagarin (he came back, just for this!) who unfortunately didn’t leave a real e-mail address. (Thanks for the book recommendation — “Туманность Андромеды” — I’ll give it a try.) But, like I said, it was an interesting letter so I’ll post some here and then address it a little bit:

It’s nice to see a non-russian who is curious about our culture. That “Moscow-Petushki” post is not bad, not bad at all.

However, I find it quite russophobic and I’m surprised, because you don’t seem like a russophobe.

I do think that this “Moscow-Petushki” post is russophobic because it is based around alcoholism and depression. You could have made a post about something else – Russia is full of historical aspects that are not in any way connected to alcoholism and depression.

I have to disagree that the Moscow-Petushki post (and the book itself) is particularly “Russophobic” — I think it was a natural exploration of a different side of Russia, rather than simply the beautiful, magical parts of Moscow. All I can say is that I think it’s important to remember not only the good, but bad aspects of someone’s history. I’ve been exploring Moscow for the past three years and have posted many (many, many) examples of wonderful things to do and places to visit.

I don’t leave posts all over internet about your people killing and raping indians and calling it a “discovery of america”. When, in fact, it was a disgusting massacre. An annexation of a land that never was yours, never will be.

Well, yes. And I thank you for not doing that, my anonymous Russian. However, I will say that Americans themselves openly acknowledge that atrocities like this happen. America has done awful things in the name of America: destroying native races, oppressing people of color, not to mention the countless wars we’ve started over the years. Trust me, you don’t need to convince me that America (the government) is pretty awful. I don’t assume people talking about those parts of our history are anti-American, I think they’re acknowledging a powerful part of the past in order to process it and try to move past it. That’s healthy.

I love my second home in Russia — acknowledging that somewhere has negatives doesn’t negate that fact in the least! I guess what I want everyone to take away from this is that this blog usually talks about Russia and America — not Russians and Americans. I think it’s important to distinguish between them because while governments differ, in general, as people we’re all quite similar. No matter which passport we have, some of us are drunks, some of us are cosmonauts, and most of us are just normal people.

I’m interested in hearing your opinions: when living (or visiting) a foreign culture, is it appropriate to criticize? Where do you draw the line?

EVEN MORE CONTENT
Join hundreds of other AG&HT readers who are getting a monthly round-up of all that's weird and wonderful in Russia. PLUS you'll gain access to an e-mail list only short story that really pulls back the cover on what life's really like in Russia.
PS. No spam. Ever.

4 Responses

  1. I think anyone reading your blog will know that you’re the opposite of russophobic…! You’ve been there for long enough to have an informed opinion, and, as with all opinions, somebody is going to disagree. Some people can be very touch about certain things, we all have out ‘button issues’, which we allow to get pushed all too keenly at times.

    The “like” box has disappeared again. Yes, I AM criticising ;-)

  2. Katie says:

    I think it’s definitely important to have a critical and analytic mind towards ANYTHING in life. That doesn’t mean be a pessimist, just staying open and informed and trying your best not to look at things either through rose or otherwise tinted glasses. And I think you do that! I remember Aeroflot published excerpts of my blog in their inflight magazine and the parts they chose were all sarcastic, tongue in cheek (I thought) observations I had. Meanwhile, 90% of my other posts were about how much I loved Russia! You can’t have all good jut like you can’t have all bad. A healthy dose of criticism coming from someone who’s lived in a country for three years is perfectly fine! Plus I don’t recall you EVER posting anything about the discovery of America. :)

    Kudos to you for posting Yuri’s email and thanks also to the cosmonaut himself (I have a keychain of you!) for broaching this subject. It’s definitely an interesting one and discussion and debate is always good!

  3. gkm2011 says:

    I think the most important thing about commenting on a culture not your own is to admit that our backgrounds make what is normal different. As long as that is clear – anything goes, as long as it is written politely and thoughtfully.

  4. oh my. you write what you see and experience. ugh. not everyone will have the same opinion. but it’s your experiences on this blog, not theirs. i’d rather hear an honest opinion – good/bad instead of sugar coated.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>